Worthy of note is that all 13 companies reported on the four topics of interest to capital markets: connection to management strategies, human-capital risks, outcome KPI disclosure, and connection to financial indicators. This is probably a reflection of human capital reports’ origins as an element of companies’ dialogue with investors.
Next, of the topics of interest to the labor market, six were also subject of disclosures by all 13 companies. Specifically, they are human capital portfolio management, transparency of personnel assignment decisions, training systems, knowledge sharing and learning culture, gender equality, and employee health. All are metrics telling existing and potential employees what kind of human-resource development and working conditions the companies offer. This indicates how human capital reports have begun to facilitate dialogue with the labor market.
Meanwhile, among other topics of interest to the labor market, only a few companies address reskilling and retraining. This is in contrast to training programs, which is covered by all 13 companies’ reports. The relative absence of the reskilling and retraining topic is representative of how low little priority companies give such initiatives.
As a general trend, human capital reports evolved from being a tool in the overall system of disclosure to gradually taking on a broader, dual purpose: Telling the story of what and how much companies are doing to create value through human capital (which is of interest to capital markets), and communicating progress on specific human-resources initiatives (which is of interest to the labor market). Our analysis confirms this shift, and it also reveals that inconsistencies in the content of labor market-oriented disclosure—what and how much companies disclose—emerge easily between companies. This reflects differences in how experienced companies are in translating human-capital concepts into practice.
Through separate analysis, we have found that price book-value ratio (PBR) and total factor productivity (TFP) are influenced by the coverage of human-capital management strategies in investor-facing reports, including integrated reports (IRs) and securities reports. Meanwhile, real examples of human capital reports show that their publishers have greater freedom of scope for what and how much they choose to disclose on human capital compared to what is permitted in IRs and securities reports. As a medium, human capital reports give them room to dig deeper and cover human capital with greater depth and breadth. The implication is that human capital reports are optimal for systematically and frankly reporting on how and to what extent companies’ human capital strategies contribute to corporate growth, achieving their strategies, and realizing their ambitions.