As described above, COP31 involves a variety of issues beyond its main agenda items. The success or failure of COP31 therefore cannot be measured solely by progress in the formal negotiations on the agenda, but should also be assessed from the perspective of maintaining multilateral cooperation. The reality of international climate negotiations over the past two to three years is that the confrontation between developed and developing countries, a long-standing undercurrent in international negotiations, has come to the surface in the absence of negotiation items that would constitute major milestones, and COP31 is no exception. Moreover, given that the United States is not expected to engage substantively in the negotiations, reaching an agreement that would make its future re-entry difficult would be counterproductive. It is therefore reasonable not to expect significant progress in the negotiations.
Turning to the positions of participating countries, the confrontation between developed and developing countries can be characterized as one between the European Union, which promotes globally common action using tools such as the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), and many developing countries, which oppose this on the basis of "common but differentiated responsibilities"4 and call on developed countries to take the lead in action and provide finance. In contrast, Japan and other non-EU developed countries such as Australia and Canada are closer to an intermediate position.
Meeting developing countries' calls for financial contributions is difficult for every country, and Japan is no exception. On the other hand, it is now becoming increasingly clear that the damage from climate change will not wait for stalled international negotiations. Against this backdrop, it is hoped that the "Umbrella Group", to which Australia, which is running COP31, belongs together with Japan, Canada and others, will work with Türkiye, which is keen to make the conference a success, to find a way forward. It is hoped that the increasingly visible impacts of climate change, together with such efforts, will foster a shared recognition of the need for multilateral cooperation and, as a result, lead to an agreement on adaptation that includes some form of support.
Meanwhile, bringing the Action Agenda—including the aforementioned initiatives on electrification and waste reduction—into the COP negotiations with specific numerical targets would impose a heavy negotiating burden and could hinder the kind of agreement described above. It is therefore hoped that, even without numerical targets, a cover decision referring to higher electrification rates, in line with the recent momentum of the energy transition, as well as further waste-reduction measures, will be adopted.
If such an agreement helps ease, even slightly, the deadlock between developed and developing countries and leads to constructive discussions on the "Global Stocktake" and "just transition", COP31 could arguably be called a success.