Much of the knowledge on carbon credits to date has been developed through the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) of the Kyoto Protocol era and the voluntary credits that followed it. Neither of these were based on the assumption that emissions need to be reduced significantly, and for this reason, accumulation of knowledge on CDR projects is generally insufficient. Afforestation and forest protection (REDD+) have long been a part of carbon crediting schemes, but they are under scrutiny in light of recent claims of greenwashing and the loss of buffer pools due to large-scale wildfires.
Currently, development of methodologies applicable to CDR projects is being undertaken in the framework of the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism, in addition to several voluntary carbon credit programs. However, differences in viewpoints are still evident, an example being the draft standards for development of methodologies prepared by the Article 6.4 Methodological Expert Panel in July 2025, where the panel produced two very different proposals.
It should be noted that even the REMIND-LD scenario, which is most aggressive in terms of energy consumption reductions (Figure 2) at half of the current levels, anticipates removal of about twice as much as Japan’s total emissions. This is a much larger amount than the amount of removal that is currently being undertaken. Despite such obvious importance of removal, there is currently no universally agreed calculation method.