Carbon credits, used to offset the greenhouse gas emissions of countries and companies, became widely adopted through the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) under the Kyoto Protocol. As the Protocol effectively came to an end, however, the center of activity shifted from compliance schemes to voluntary programs utilized by the private sector. The greater flexibility inherent in voluntary programs also gave rise to doubts about the integrity of carbon credits, as reflected in greenwashing criticism concerning issues such as the over-issuance of carbon credits. Against this backdrop, CORSIA, which sets out emission reduction measures for international aviation, included carbon credits among its options. Its Emissions Unit Eligibility Criteria (EUC)1 published in 2019, consolidated prior knowledge and established requirements for carbon crediting programs and credits themselves. The Core Carbon Principles (CCP)2, adopted in 2023 by the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM), an initiative promoting the sound expansion of voluntary credit markets, further developed the EUC. Together, these frameworks are forming a shared understanding of carbon credits, referred to below as the “international standards.”
By contrast, the Japan-led Joint Crediting Mechanism (JCM) developed along a different path. Unlike many other crediting programs, the JCM has not codified, in a program-wide and uniform form, rules concerning baseline scenario establishment, demonstration of additionality, renewal of crediting periods, or responses to non-permanence (the risk of reversal). Instead, these matters are established for individual partner countries or projects. Progress also varies among partner countries in developing registry systems capable of tracking the transfer and use (retirement) of credits and preventing double counting.
These institutional differences may be attributable to several factors. The JCM originated during the Kyoto Protocol era before the Paris Agreement, and its design began in anticipation of the cooperative approaches later set out in Article 6.2 of the Paris Agreement (discussed below). In addition, Japan conducts bilateral deliberations with each of its partner countries—32 as of August 2026—and the mechanism is linked to Japan’s domestic climate measures, making uniform changes to its rules difficult. An application was previously submitted for the bilateral JCM between Japan and Mongolia to be recognized as a CORSIA-eligible program, but it has not been recognized as eligible to date.3