Mitsubishi Research Institute Response to GHG Protocol Revisions

Proposes practical and effective framework for Scope 2
and new reporting structure reflecting Japan's circumstances
18 August 2026

Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc.

18 August 2026—Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc. published its response to GHG Protocol's ongoing revisions of their corporate greenhouse gas (GHG) accounting and reporting standards. The response falls under Scope 2 public consultation and the request for information (RFI) on the Actions and Market Instruments (AMI) Phase 1 White Paper.

The firm proposes that revisions to the GHG Protocol accounting standards take into account national regulatory frameworks, market conditions, and corporate practices, while appropriately factoring in how emissions occur as well as ensuring international consistency. Revisions to the accounting standards could have far-reaching impacts not only on corporate GHG accounting, target setting, and disclosure, but also on renewable energy procurement and decarbonization-related investments.

“We will continue to closely monitor developments in international discussions on revisions to the GHG Protocol and assess their impacts on GHG accounting practices and corporate decarbonization efforts,” said Kenichiro Yamaguchi, Mitsubishi Research Institute Fellow, Energy and Sustainability who was part of the team that drew up the proposals. “Drawing on our knowledge of Japan's regulatory and market environment as well as corporate practices, we will promote information sharing and dialogue with stakeholders in Japan and abroad. In this way, we will support corporate decarbonization efforts, decarbonization-related businesses, and the advancement of renewable energy policy through research, advisory services, and communications toward the realization of a decarbonized society.”
The following is an overview of the Mitsubishi Research Institute response:



Key issues in the Scope 2 revisions include hourly matching which considers the temporal alignment between electricity generation and consumption at a more granular level, and deliverability, which evaluates whether claimed environmental attributes are supported by electricity that can realistically be delivered to the consumer. We see these concepts as helping to improve the accuracy and credibility of Scope 2 accounting over time.

However, uniform, rigorous application of hourly matching at this stage could pose excessive burden to companies, particularly in their feasibility of attaining renewable targets as well as collecting and analyzing data. Furthermore, unless reasonable load-profile methodologies are sufficiently developed for cases where hourly data is unavailable, differences in estimation methods could undermine the consistency of accounting results. Feasibility by practitioners should therefore be given due consideration through measures such as phased implementation, transitional arrangements, the development of reasonable load-profile methodologies, and the enhancement of data infrastructure by public authorities.

Deliverability could also affect cross-regional renewable energy procurement and future investment decisions, depending on how market boundaries are defined. We therefore consider it desirable for the standard to reflect electricity market structures and actual grid operations in each country when defining market boundaries. At the same time, it should provide sufficient flexibility to take into consideration existing cross-regional procurement and off-site power purchase agreements (PPAs) while aligning with policy for future grid reinforcement and the expansion of renewable energy deployment.

Japan is expanding its deployment of renewable energy, but electricity consumers do not always have access to sufficient procurement options. The country also faces a structural challenge: Major demand centers are geographically distant from regions with high renewable-energy potential. Through initiatives such as the master plan for cross-regional grid development, the government and relevant organizations are upgrading the transmission system to deliver electricity from areas suited to renewable generation to demand centers, with the aim of maximizing renewable energy deployment.

If a narrow delineation of market boundary in defining deliverability is applied in a formalistic and rigid manner without adequately reflecting these circumstances in Japan, investment appetite for corporate PPAs and similar arrangements in the country could decline. For example, our analysis indicates that if hourly matching and deliverability were applied at the level of Japan's 10 regional electricity areas (i.e. the most granular definition of market boundaries not considering the interconnection between them), the amount of solar power available to consumers in Tokyo would fall to roughly 10% of current levels (see "GHGプロトコル改定による再エネ調達への影響" [Impact of GHG Protocol revisions on renewable energy procurement]). It is our hope that the revisions to the GHG Protocol will not only enhance the accuracy and credibility of GHG accounting, but also support the expansion of renewable energy deployment and the achievement of decarbonization.
The results of the Scope 2 public consultation were published on 29 July 2026. They showed that the majority of respondents were cautious about putting the revised standard into practice due to concerns that it could discourage market participation and impose burdens, administrative and otherwise. Results also showed significant variation among geographic regions with respondents from Eastern Asia showing the highest degree of reluctance. Various solutions were suggested as compromises by respondents, including relaxing the requirements through optional application and broader market boundaries, as well as making exemptions based on region and organization size. The results seem to broadly align with our views that caution must be exercised if the standard is to be revised.

The AMI workstream includes consideration of a multi-statement GHG reporting structure, where data of varying characteristics are presented as separate reporting statements. Such a format could be useful for making corporate decarbonization actions and the effects of market instruments visible. If the standard were to treat the procurement and provision of low-carbon products and services, market-based instruments such as certificates and carbon credits, and avoided emissions separately from the physical GHG inventory, companies would be able to more appropriately demonstrate their contributions to decarbonization. However, the framework could undermine comparability among companies and the credibility of reporting unless it clearly defines items such as accounting methodologies, quality standards, the relationships among different statements, safeguards against double counting, and their linkage to target setting.

To address these issues, our response includes proposals on issues such as the extent of market-based GHG inventory, the contents of GHG impact statements, guidelines for non-GHG indicators, the distinction between voluntary and mandatory elements, and the issues to be addressed in Phase 2.

In Japan, there have been multiple discussions on avoided emissions, and efforts are underway to develop guidance documents. Initiatives have involved the public and private sectors, academia, and other relevant stakeholders while focusing on how to quantify and disclose the contribution of products, services, and other solutions to economy-wide GHG emissions reductions. Key issues include frameworks for reporting avoided emissions separately from, but as a complement to, the physical GHG inventory; baselines; additionality; conservativeness; transparency of accounting methodologies; the prevention and management of double counting; and the relationship with market-based instruments such as carbon credits and certificates.

We believe that the purpose of avoided emissions should not simply be a measure of offsetting a company's own emissions. Rather, they should be used as information that demonstrates a company's contribution to decarbonization, under a consistent methodology grounded on international consensus.

About Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc.

Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc. is one of Japan’s foremost think tanks. For over 50 years, it has provided the public and private sectors with research and consulting services in fields spanning sustainability, the environment, energy, healthcare, human resources, and digital transformation. This is accompanied by policy recommendations and the real-world application of solutions. Mitsubishi Research Institute will continue to envision the future, resolve societal issues, and lead change to build a sustainable and prosperous world. For more information, please visit: www.mri.co.jp/en/

For more information

General contact

Kenichiro Yamaguchi, Mari Iwahashi, Naoto Wabiko, Ami Togami, Tomoyuki Nagamura, and Katsura Fukuda
Green Transformation Division,
Energy and Sustainability Unit
Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc.
10-3, Nagatacho 2-chome, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 100-8141, Japan
E-mail:ghg-protocol-update@ml.mri.co.jp

Media contact

Corporate Communications Division
Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc.
10-3, Nagatacho 2-chome, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 100-8141, Japan
E-mail: media@mri.co.jp

News